Chocolate Protein Ice Cream - Pantry Challenge!
Table of Contents
This ultra-creamy, Chocolate Protein Ice Cream is dairy-free, soy-free, nut-free and has a secret and totally unexpected ingredient - split peas! This sweet treat is a great way to use up some split peas without making soup, and by adding extra protein to your desserts. Give it a try! Plus, there's a no-churn option!

If you didn't see my last post, this month is all about using up your "abandoned" pantry ingredients in fun and delicious ways. You can follow the posts and recipes by checking out the #VYApantrychallenge hashtag on pretty much any social media platform. Though, I do favor Instagram and post how-to IG stories there pretty frequently!

And, to be extra helpful - plus, try and stick to my two-a-month promise - I made another cooking video for you. You can find that on my YouTube channel, and also right before the recipe if you scroll down a little bit. As with the two recent videos before it, there was a technical issue with a piece of equipment and we got stuck with one camera angle, but I think it works well! (THANK YOU, COREY)

Now, back to this ice cream. I can't tell you specifically how this idea came to me, I think it was a really fast 10 degrees of another thought. But, when it happened, I was like, "this will either be super gross, or pretty awesome." After making a recipe for Blood Orange Hibiscus ice cream with it first (which is also below), I tried out the chocolate protein ice cream-version. And, hot damn! I'm super loving this new way to make ice cream.

The chocolate, and optional coffee, flavors hide the peas easily, and I don't think I'd ever guess they were in there. That sounds like a successful recipe to me! So, if you have some split peas in your pantry (which many of you said you did), you will love this untraditional take on the way to eat them. Sidenote: a ½ cup uncooked split peas contains nearly 25 grams of protein!

Let me know if you make this chocolate protein ice cream in the comments below, or tag me on your social media posts! And if you're feeling inspired by this series, use the hashtag #VYApantrychallenge so that I can check out what you're making using your forgotten items. <3
1 year: Butternut Squash Bacon Soup // 2 years: The Taco Cleanse // 3 years: Vegan Kluski // 4 years: Cool Ranch Roasted Chickpeas // 5 years: Thai Curry Cauliflower // 6 years: Raw Chocolate Mousse Pie
Chocolate Protein Ice Cream
This ultra-creamy, Chocolate Protein Ice Cream is dairy-free, soy-free, nut-free and has a secret and totally unexpected ingredient - split peas! Plus, there’s a no-churn option! #vegan #glutenfree #recipe
Ingredients
- ½ cup yellow split peas
- 1 ¼ cups water
- 13.5 ounce can coconut cream or full-fat coconut milk
- ⅓ cup cocoa powder
- 6-8 tablespoons maple syrup or agave nectar
- 1 ½ teaspoons vanilla extract
- ¾ teaspoon xanthan gum
- Pinch of salt
- 2 teaspoons instant coffee granules, OPTIONAL
Instructions
- Stove top: Bring the split peas and water to a boil in a small pot, over medium-high heat. Cover and adjust heat to medium-low, and boil for 35-45 minutes or until very tender, adding more water if necessary. Remove from heat, transfer to a bowl and refrigerate for 20 minutes.
- Pressure cooker/instant pot: Bring split peas and water to high-pressure and cook for 8-10 minutes. Quick release pressure, transfer to a bowl and refrigerate for 20 minutes.
- After the peas have cooled, place them in a blender along with coconut cream, cocoa powder, maple syrup/agave nectar, vanilla, xanthan gum, and salt (and optional coffee granules). Puree until completely smooth; like, VERY smooth.
- Now, you can either transfer to an ice cream maker, and run it for 25 minutes, then enjoy as soft serve or freeze for an additional 20 minutes to harden. When you go to store it in the freezer again, make sure the next time you take it out, you allow it to defrost for 5 to 10 minutes to get a good scoop.
- No-churn: Transfer ice cream base to a gallon-sized zip bag, and freeze until firm. Break the ice cream slab up into chunks and place it in your food processor, process with an s-blade until creamy, then return to the freezer for 30 minutes. Top with cacao nibs or chocolate sauce and enjoy!
Notes
You can find xanthan gum in most baking aisles or near specialty flours, but if you cannot find it, replace with 1 tablespoon arrowroot. It will not be as fluffy, but it will help.
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
8Serving Size:
1 gramsAmount Per Serving: Unsaturated Fat: 0g






Jackie, you are simply brilliant! Thank you for posting the recipes and for making the video. The ice cream looks delicious. Split peas in ice cream? YES! You inspire us to think outside of the box. Looking forward to playing with this recipe.
You are so sweet!! Thank you for the very kind words and you'll have to let me know how it goes! <3
Can't wait to try this recipe out!!
I just love ice cream 🙂
Yay! Let me know if you end up making it! 😀
Would you believe Sprouts doesn't carry yellow lentils?! So weird. What are your thoughts on subbing red lentils? Or I have Chana Dal and Toor Dal at home - would those be a fine sub?
Hi Jenna! I used yellow split peas for this recipe, not lentils. I did get these at Sprouts though, in the bulk area! I think chana dal is similar, so you could try that out. Good luck! 🙂
What an amazing recipe! I'll have to try this out. Thank you for sharing!
These looks great! Can I use canned sweet peas for this recipe and possibly leave out th blood orange? Thanks so much
Are you referencing the Blood Orange version? You can leave it out but there won't be much of a flavor, and I wouldn't use sweet peas instead, as the flavor will be much different.
Not a big chocolate ice cream fan, but a HUGE blood orange fan. And I love hibiscus as well. I can't wait to try the "alternate" version--there's a mango hibiscus soy "milk"shake at a diner I like--this may be the key to me reproducing those flavors at home. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!
My grandma would love this recipe, she was always looking for a way to make her leftover ingredients go the extra mile. In efforts to cook like her, I decided to take some Culinary Education classes. I was a pretty good cook, but my skills have heightened to a whole new level. I have tons of fun when I am in class and am trying foods that I have never tried before. I am glad I decided to do this for myself and my grandma would be so proud of me!
Thank you so much for your post and I am very eager to try the recipe...however I have green split peas, not yellow, Is it a reasonable substitution? Is the final color the issue?
Thank you
Sorry, Yolanda, just seeing this! I think green would work fine here!
Would cream of tater be a suitable substitute for the xanthan gum/arrowroot? I have neither.
Hi Heather! It would not, as it is not a thickener. Corn starch will work, though, if you heat it a little first.